Blog/AI slop
AI video tools: what each kind is actually good for
Avatars, generated footage, synthetic voice, auto-clips, editing assistants. Each one does a job well. Most teams hand them a different job.
Kevin Blanco··7 min read·Every stage
The short answer
AI video tools are good at jobs that have a known answer: transcripts, captions, translations, resizing and rough cuts. They are poor at jobs that need judgment about a viewer, like choosing the idea, writing the script and deciding what to show. Give each tool a job with a known answer, and keep a person on the rest.
01
It isn't one thing
"AI video" gets talked about as if it were a single tool. It's five or six, and they do different jobs.
Most of the money that goes wrong goes wrong at the same step. Someone buys a tool that's very good at one job, then points it at another. The avatar licence that was meant for translated training ends up fronting a product tutorial. The clip finder that was meant to shortlist moments gets set to publish on its own.
So start with the tool, not the idea. What is each one actually for?
02
Five kinds of tool, one job each
This is our view, from using them on client work. It names kinds of tool because the products change every few months and the jobs don't.
| Kind of tool | Good for | Falls over when | Our verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| AI presenters (avatars) | Translated narration, compliance training, internal how-tos | The video has to show a real person using the real product | Use rarely |
| Text-to-video and generated b-roll | Mood shots, abstract backgrounds, storyboard frames | It has to show your UI or your code: generated screens are wrong in ways engineers notice | Storyboards only |
| Synthetic voice and dubbing | Draft narration, localization, fixing one flubbed line | It has to carry a personality, or say product names and acronyms | Use with a native speaker's check |
| Transcription, captions, chapters | Transcripts, captions, chapters, searchable text | Almost never, as long as someone checks the product names | Use every time |
| Editing assistants | A first-pass cut, silence removal, finding the best 40 seconds of a talk, reframing for vertical | It has to choose the hook and the story: they tend to pick moments that are loud, not useful | Use for the first pass |
03
Where the money goes
- 01
The avatar on the tutorial
Meant for translated training. Ends up fronting a product tutorial, where the viewer wants to see the real product run and a real error get fixed.
- 02
The Shorts factory
Clips cut and published automatically from every talk. Nobody chose the moment, wrote the hook or added a next step, so nobody has a reason to watch or act.
- 03
Generated b-roll over an unplanned script
Pretty footage on top of a script nobody decided on. The video looks finished and says nothing a developer could use.
04
A five-question test for any task
Before a tool takes a task, run it through this. It works on tools that don't exist yet.
The test
Should AI do this one?
Tick every question you can answer yes to.
Keep a person on it
0 / 5
This one is judgment. Use AI for the transcript and the first cut, and make the decisions yourself.
05
What AI needs from you
The tasks that pass the test still go better with a brief. A page is enough. Most generic output comes from a missing brief, not a weak tool.
A one-page brief for AI-assisted video
Voice: direct, first person, short sentences. No "unlock", no "seamless". Always show: the real product, a real cursor, a real terminal. Never show: stock laptops, generated screens, invented UI. Names: spell products as their owners do (ngrok is lowercase). Review: one named person approves. Reject the first draft by default. Measure: one number, decided before the video is made.
FAQ
Questions people ask
Is AI-generated video worth it for developer content?
For jobs with a known answer, yes: transcripts, captions, translations, resizing and rough cuts. For the idea, the script and what to show, no. Those depend on judgment about the viewer, and developers notice when nobody made them.
What are AI avatar videos good for?
Translated narration, compliance training and internal how-tos, where the viewer has to finish. They work poorly for product demos and tutorials, where viewers want to see the real product run.
Can AI generate a product demo?
Generated footage can't show your real product accurately. Screens, code and behavior come out wrong in ways engineers spot quickly. Record the real product, and use AI for transcripts, captions, translations and the first rough cut.
How should I use AI for Shorts?
Use a clip finder to shortlist moments from a talk, then have a person choose, write the hook and add a next step. Clips published automatically, picked for loudness, rarely give viewers a reason to act.
What goes in a brief for AI-assisted video?
Voice rules, words to avoid, what to always show and never show, how product names are spelled, who approves, and the one number you'll measure.
DevReel
How we do it at DevReel
We use AI every week, on the jobs with a known answer. The idea, the script and the cut stay with people who have used the product, and every video has a viewer, a journey stage and a number before anyone starts.
Cloudinary's videos usually average around 400 views. Ours passed 9,000 in the first week. For ngrok, watch hours tripled and subscribers went from about 450 to over 800 in the first week.
Cloudinary views
9,000+
in the first week, against a usual ~400
ngrok watch hours
3×
subscribers from ~450 to 800+ in the first week
Now the hard part
Tell us which AI tools your team has bought and what they're being used for. We'll tell you which jobs to keep and which to hand back.

Kevin Blanco founded DevReel. He has made 500+ developer-tool videos and spoken at 80+ developer conferences.
Keep reading
AI slop/Every stage
Where AI helps a video team, stage by stage
Planning, capture, edit, polish, publish: each stage has a part AI does well and a part a person has to decide. Here is the split.
September 15, 2026·7 min read→AI slop/Every stage
What an AI video really costs you
The subscription is the cheap line on the bill. The expensive ones are review time, rework and the videos nobody uses.
September 4, 2026·7 min read→AI slop/Every stage
Developers can spot AI slop in three seconds
Developers don't comment on a video they don't trust. They close the tab. This is what they notice in those three seconds, and what to make instead.
August 18, 2026·7 min read→